Thursday, December 10, 2015

[Esther 10] The Epilogue

The story of Esther could have ended just as it ended in Esther 9. Esther and Mordecai win; Haman loses. The good guys win; the bad guys lose. But what’s a good story without a happily ever after? That’s what Esther 10 is: our happily ever after. Some consider Esther 10 another scene in our 3-act play. I see it more as an epilogue. An epilogue is a conclusion to a story that gives full closure. Esther 10 will conclude the story of Esther in a way that gives full closure, so we know confidently that the people of God will live happily ever after.

Esther 10 closes the book of Esther the same way Esther 1 opens the book: proclaiming the greatness of King Xerxes. This time, however, very little is said about Xerxes. Esther 10:1 mentions that Xerxes imposed an empire-wide tax. This seems like an odd way to end a story. In their Commentary, Critical and Explanatory, on the Whole Bible, Robert Jamieson, A.R. Fausset and David Brown suggest it could be to compensate for the hole in the state budget due to not receiving Haman’s funds. On the contrary, Mervin Breneman, author of The New American Commentary: Ezra, Nehemiah, Esther, suggests the tax is to contrast Haman’s funding to the treasury in exchange for the lives of the Jews. The king remains prosperous even with this tax and without Haman’s funds. Carl Keil and Franz Delitzsche, in their Commentary on the Old Testament, propose the tax funded the Purim festival. In Be Committed, Warren W. Wiersbe suggests that tax was on the work and the money of the Jews. If the Jews would have died at the hands of Haman, Xerxes would have never received this money. Now that the Jews could live, the king would prosper off their work and their living, far beyond if the Jews were dead. Or just maybe it’s demonstrating his great power, in his ability to decree and enforce a tax to the far ends of his kingdom. Either way, this is King Xerxes’s happily ever after. For everything else, Esther 10:2 tells the reader to look them up in the official Persian historical records. Unfortunately, to this day, we don’t have most of those records, and furthermore, the Greeks didn’t have a lot to say about him either. Besides that, that’s it.

Esther 10 also closes out with the greatness of Mordecai. Everything else focuses on Mordecai. Notice that Mordecai’s greatness rests on his position in the empire. Note the text says nothing about Mordecai being a righteous Jew or devoutly following the law. He is a good Jew because of his position in the Persian Empire and what he did for the Jews. Speaking of which, notice chapter 10 only credits Mordecai for saving the Jews and not Queen Esther. Mordecai’s pride and Esther’s absentness have left scholars in their textual criticism to doubt Mordecai wrote this chapter, believing it was added later. Sadly, Esther’s absence just might be old fashion sexism. Since Esther did her part of intervening with the king, she is no longer needed. She probably had little to no power when it comes to administering government power. Probably, in King Xerxes’s eyes, just like other kings of that, her sole purpose was now bearing sons. Since the book of Esther does not concern itself with the king’s children, Esther role as mother of the king’s children need not to be mentioned.

While the statement about Mordecai might sound like prideful boasting (especially if Mordecai is the author), the statement also shows some attributes of Mordecai’s character than the reader can learn from. Just as Mordecai put the welfare of his people before his own wellbeing, the reader comes to realize that we cannot truly love our neighbor until we put them fully before ourselves. Just as Mordecai spoke up for a victimized people, the reader learns not to fear defending the poor and weak in society. Both of these life lessons learned from Mordecai come in great contrast to Haman. Remember Haman used his second-in-command power to put himself first and to overpower the small and weak of the empire. In contrast, Mordecai used that power to lift his people up and empower them. Now the reader learns a third lesson: whenever in power, we should use it in a wise and godly way. That way will involve loving other and help the poor, needy and weak.

So the book of Esther ends with this 3-verse epilogue in chapter 10. It contains the greatness of Xerxes, the greatness of Mordecai, and no mention of Esther. That’s it. Like I said above, the book of Esther would have ended just fine without this epilogue. But I believe the Bible has no fillers, so the reader has to ask what the purpose of this epilogue is. Look back at the text again, but more closely. We have Xerxes, supportive of the Jews, as king on the throne. Second to the king is the Jew Mordecai. With a Jew and a Jewish supporter as the two most powerful men up on top, the Jews living all over the Persian Empire must have felt peace and safety. They no longer had to fear any man or men trying to use the government to harm or oppress the people because they had a Jew and a Jew supporter as the top two men of the government, who would protect the Jews from any such attack. Persian records record a new name for the grand vizier position, which dates to around 465 BC. I bet all the way up to that point, the Jews felt this peace and safety, knowing the Jew Mordecai and the Jew supporter Xerxes kept a faithful watch of the Jews’ wellbeing. This was a blessing from God, that came out of his providence.
 
 

When I spent the summer of 2009 in Israel, I noticed some shops selling a certain t-shirt. This t-shirt listed all the nations that stood up against the Jews, and then it recorded them all as “gone.” It even listed Iran as “????.” The bottom of t-shirt said, “The Jewish Nation: The smallest of nations with a friend in the highest of places. SO…BE NICE!” I didn’t buy the shirt, for I didn’t think I agreed with it, but now I wish I did, for it would have created a nice illustration for Esther chapter 10. I invite you to look beyond the shirt’s prideful, arrogant cockiness, and I invite you to make the connection to the book of Esther. Prior to the book of Esther, the Jews ran into conflict with the Egyptians, Philistines, Assyrians and Babylonians. Each one of those civilizations attempted to exterminate the Jews, yet each one ended being exterminated, and the Jews survived and thrived. Add Persia to the list. Haman intended to exterminate the Jews, only for himself and his family to be exterminated. Later on, even Persia would die out (its remnants are the modern-day nations of Iraq and Iran), but the Jews would still be there. A Jewish reader of the book of Esther would look on this past of God siding with the Jews, and he or she could look towards the future in hope, believing God would act the same. I mentioned this in Esther chapter 4. In Esther 4, Mordecai could speak about a deliver to Esther with such boldness because he knew the history of God saving his people the Jews. Add now the Jews living in Persia during the events of the book of Esther. God intervened for Esther. Now the Jewish reader should share in the same hope Mordecai had in Esther 4.

For the Christians, who are also God’s people, the lesson remains the same. Reading the book of Esther, we see how God intervenes in the lives of His people to give them hope, peace, safety and blessing. Therefore, the Christian reader can also hope in a future of peace, safety and blessing. This hope can be for the present, when things may not be going the way the Christian would have hoped. But this hope even extends to the future. The hope seen in the book of Esther is the same hope found in the book of Revelation. We can hope in a peaceful and secure future because we know God is actively involved in the past, present and future. And that future involves God and his people winning at the end, just like Esther and Mordecai led the Jews into winning over the bad guys.

I guess the best way to end this story is the way any good tale ends. “And they lived happily ever after.” J

No comments:

An Evaluation of Children's Church Songs

I have an atypical daughter. Despite all the baby books stating that infants sleep 10-12 hours during the night, along with 2 hour-long naps...